How To Tell If Coffee Is Bad: 5 Signs
Picture this: It’s Monday morning, and you’ve just woken up for the day. You drag yourself out of bed, make breakfast, and sit down to enjoy a nice cup of joe — only to be greeted by a bad taste and musty smell.
As much as we love coffee, it’s best to avoid coffee that’s gone bad, if only because of the subpar flavor. You can avoid the above scenario by simply taking a peek at your coffee grounds every now and then to check whether they’re still good. Read on for five ways to tell if your coffee is bad, as well as some tips on how to keep it fresher for longer.
5 Signs Your Coffee Is Bad
The key to avoiding an unpleasant cup of coffee is to catch expired coffee before you brew it up and drink it. Read on for five things to look for to ensure you stay away from bad coffee.
1. Mold
Let’s be real — if your coffee looks like it’s auditioning for a biology experiment, it’s time to let it go. Mold, which usually looks like white or green fuzzy patches, is a dead giveaway that your coffee has gone bad. This can happen if your grounds or beans have been exposed to moisture.
2. Change in Color
Fresh coffee should boast a rich, chocolatey brown color. If your coffee beans or grounds are looking dull or ashy, that’s your cue to toss them. Prolonged exposure to air can rob coffee of its vibrant color, which is also an indicator of how it will taste. Trust us when we say this subpar coffee is not worthy of your morning ritual.
3. Loss of Aroma
Who doesn’t love the intoxicating aroma of fresh coffee? It’s the reason we crawl out of bed in the morning. Some people even buy candles and air fresheners specifically to keep this smell around all day long.
If your coffee doesn’t smell like heaven on earth, it’s probably stale. Coffee loses its aroma when its oils break down, which usually happens due to oxygen exposure.
4. Faded Flavor
Coffee is meant to be a complex sensory experience, rich in subtle notes and bursts of flavor. If your brew tastes flat, lifeless, or just "meh," it’s past its prime. Over time, coffee’s natural compounds degrade, which will also erode its flavor and aroma.
5. Extra Bitterness
While coffee should have a little bite, a cup that’s overly bitter is no good. This harsh flavor often results from beans that are a little too old for comfort. When beans sit on the shelf for too long, their oils oxidize and turn rancid. If your coffee tastes more like a punishment than a pleasure, it’s time to replace your stash.
Why Does Coffee Go Bad?
Coffee goes bad primarily due to oxidation. Exposure to oxygen breaks down the oils and flavor compounds that give coffee its signature aroma and taste. Over time, these compounds degrade, leaving behind a stale, lifeless brew.
Heat, moisture, and light can make this process even faster, putting your coffee on the fast track to going stale. While it’s not harmful or dangerous to drink, old coffee is far from the flavorful experience you might be used to. If your morning cuppa is the best part of your day, you’ll want to avoid bad coffee as much as you can.
How Can You Keep Your Coffee From Going Bad?
If your coffee is stale, the best thing you can do is toss it — it will not bring you joy. Afterward, hike on over to the store and pick out a new bag of beans.
Once you have your fresh coffee, take steps to make sure your coffee stays flavorful and aromatic. Here are a few tips to help you enjoy your coffee for longer.
Proper Storage
To extend your coffee’s shelf life, store it in an airtight container away from light, heat, and moisture. Exposure to these elements accelerates oxidation, which is no bueno for your favorite brew.
Choose a container with a rubber gasket to keep air out, and place it in a cool, dark spot, like a pantry or cabinet. You can even look for containers specifically designed to store coffee. We know coffee bags can be interesting and pretty, but resist the urge to store your coffee in its original packaging — it’s often not airtight enough to lock in freshness.
Be Intentional in the Store
When you’re shopping for coffee, check the roast date and origin. Coffee is freshest within two to four weeks of roasting, as it starts oxidizing the moment it’s done roasting. To avoid a bad taste, aim to buy beans with a recent roast date.
Knowing the origin can also help you choose high-quality beans that stay fresh longer. Expiration dates are helpful guides, but freshness trumps all — don’t rely solely on best-by dates if you’re after the best taste.
Grind as Needed
Pre-ground coffee loses flavor quickly due to its increased surface area, which exposes it to oxygen. Instead, buy whole beans and grind only what you need for each brew.
We know it’s time consuming, but this preserves the delicate oils and aromas that make coffee so delicious. And really, isn’t that worth the extra couple of minutes? A quality grinder is a worthwhile investment, ensuring your cup is consistently fresh and flavorful. Your morning coffee ritual deserves nothing less!
Freeze It
Freezing coffee can help extend its shelf life if you do it right. Store coffee in small, airtight bags to prevent exposure to moisture and odors.
Thaw only the portion you need and avoid repeatedly freezing and defrosting, as this can degrade your coffee worse than if you just left it on the counter. While freezing doesn’t stop oxidation entirely, it significantly slows the process.
The Bottom Line
Coffee is the best part of many people’s mornings, but in order to have a pleasant wake-up ritual, it’s important to make sure your coffee is actually fresh. Old coffee can look and smell faded and may taste bland or bitter.
That being said, you can keep your coffee fresher for longer if you store it properly, grind only what you need, and buy coffee that was roasted recently. If coffee flavor is the most important thing to you, check out our Mushroom Coffee+ — not only does it boast a rich flavor, but it’s also loaded with functional ingredients to help support your overall health. Try it for yourself today!
Sources:
How to Store Coffee Beans | NCAUSA
